Precedent set by having chronic pain case deemed as a catastrophic

Apr 04, 2011

After being struck by a car in August 2006, Mr. Jaggernauth sustained multiple serious injuries, including fractures of his cervical spine, right forearm and left shoulder. He also incurred deep lacerations to his head and right calf. As a result of the injury, Mr. Jaggernauth underwent surgeries to both shoulders and his right forearm.

Since the accident, Mr. Jaggernauth has not been able to return to work and suffers from chronic pain as well as a loss of sensation in his right forearm. He has been diagnosed with numerous psychological conditions for which he continues to receive treatment. He also requires several medications for his physical and psychological pain.

Mr. Jaggernauth made a claim for accident benefits from his own insurer, Economical. While they paid some ongoing benefits, Economical argued that,despite the seriousness of his injuries, Mr. Jaggernauth did not suffer from a "catastrophic impairment" as defined in the Statutory Accident Benefits Schedule. The schedule entitles persons suffering from impairments that are deemed "catastrophic" to claim from an enhanced level of accident benefits for increased housekeeping, attendant care and medical and rehabilitation expenses.

Mr. Jaggernauth was represented by Kelley Campbell of Carranza LLP. Over the course of the hearing Ms. Campbell presented evidence from Mr. Jaggerauth, his wife, a number of his healthcare providers and experts who assessed him on the issue of catastrophic impairment. The insurer presented their own experts on the issue of catastrophic impairment.


While there were numerous issues in dispute, this hearing focused on one key question—did Mr. Jaggernauth sustain a catastrophic impairment as defined in the Statutory Accident Benefits schedule?

After 8 days of evidence and a day of closing arguments, Arbitrator Richard Feldman determined that Mr. Jaggernauth did in fact sustain a catastrophic impairment considering both the physical and psychological impairments that he suffered in the motor vehicle accident. This allows Mr. Jaggernauth to maintain his claims for ongoing housekeeping and attendant care benefits as well as claims for necessary medical and rehabilitation expenses up to $1,000,000.00.


get answers now

did you know?

Distracted driving is cited as a causal factor in 30 to 50 per cent of traffic collisions on Ontario.

Source: Ontario Provincial Police

Car Accident Timelines

You have 10 business days to provide the insurance company information after it requests, or it can suspend or deny your benefits.

  • 7


    You must inform the Accident Benefits insurance company of the accident and that you were hurt. MORE

  • 30


    You must complete and send the Accident Benefits application within 30 days of it being provided to you by the insurance company. MORE

  • 120


    You need to give written notice of your intention to sue the at-fault parties. MORE

  • 2


    To commence a lawsuit against an at-fault driver or your own insurance company if your benefits are denied. MORE


All of the information on this site has been provided by Carranza LLP, Canada’s first ISO 9001:2008 certified personal injury law firm.

1280 Finch Ave. West, Suite 200

Toronto, Ontario Canada

M3J 3K6

T: 1-877-633-1065

F: 416-633-9782

To reach us by email please contact

Disclaimer: This website is meant as a general reference for injured persons and their families. The medical and legal information contained in this manual is not intended to offer legal or medical advice. The content of this website is for informational and educational purposes only and is not intended as a substitute for the professional judgment of a legal and/or healthcare professional, and you should not rely upon any material or statements made on this website for legal or medical advice. It is not intended to create a solicitor-client relationship. It is recommended that you review any medical information carefully with your doctor or healthcare professional before making any decisions regarding your health or recommended medical treatment. While reasonable attempts have been made to ensure the accuracy of the information on this website, our firm cannot make express or implied representations or warranties about the accuracy or completeness of the information. Each person's legal needs are unique, and these materials may not be applicable to your legal situation. Please contact an Ontario Personal Injury lawyer for a consultation on your particular personal injury matter.

Legal Marketing | Cubicle Fugitive